The Hill: Manchin objects to IRS bank-reporting proposal

Oct 26, 2021
Good Governance
In the News

THE HILL, NAOMI JAGODA

Sen. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.) on Tuesday criticized a proposal to increase the amount of information the IRS receives about bank accounts, saying he thinks it is unlikely to be included in Democrats’ social spending package.

“I think that one’s going to be gone,” Manchin said at an event hosted by The Economic Club of Washington, D.C.

Democrats are considering the IRS bank-reporting proposal as a way to raise revenue to finance their social spending measure. It would require banks to report to the IRS the total amount of money that came in and out of an account during a year.

The Biden administration initially called for the reporting requirement to apply to accounts with more than $600 in deposits and withdrawals in a year. Last week, congressional Democrats narrowed the scope of the proposal, raising the threshold to $10,000 and excluding wage income from that amount.

Key administration officials and Democratic lawmakers argue that the proposal would help the IRS enforce tax laws against wealthy tax cheats. But banks and Republicans have been intensely attacking the proposal, saying it raises privacy concerns.

Manchin said he shared his objections to the proposal in a meeting with President Biden. He indicated that he thinks the proposal is problematic even with a $10,000 threshold. 

Manchin said he told Biden, “Do you understand how messed up that is, to think that Uncle Sam is going to be watching?”

“I told him, I said, ‘Mr. President, I don’t know what happened. This cannot happen. It’s screwed up,'” Manchin added. The West Virginia Democrat said that Biden expressed support for his arguments.

The Hill has reached out to the White House about Manchin’s comments.

Manchin isn’t the only Democratic lawmaker to raise concerns about the IRS bank-reporting proposal in recent days.

Rep. Abigail Spanberger (D-Va.) said in a letter this week that she worries the proposal “might jeopardize my constituents’ rights to privacy without any clear tax law enforcement purpose.” She also expressed concern that small- and medium-sized financial institutions will face burdens in implementing the reporting requirement. 

She said raising the threshold to $10,000 “would certainly be a shift in the correct direction,” but wouldn’t full mitigate her apprehension. 

House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Richard Neal (D-Mass.) told reporters Tuesday that he thinks the IRS proposal should remain under discussion. He also said, “If Senator Manchin is going to go over the goal line with us, I think that we should be listening to some of what he has to say on it.”

Recent Posts


Oct 11, 2024
Social Security, Medicare, & Retirement

NEW: Spanberger Pens Op-Ed Urging Colleagues to Vote to Pass Her Bipartisan Bill to Eliminate WEP & GPO

The Bipartisan “Social Security Fairness Act” Would Eliminate Two Provisions of the “Social Security Act” That Unfairly Reduce Benefits for Millions of Americans Who Have Devoted Much of Their Careers to Public Service Thanks to the Congresswoman’s Effort to Force a Vote on the Legislation, the “Social Security Fairness Act” Will Come to the U.S. […]



Oct 10, 2024
Energy & Environment

Spanberger Urges Speaker Johnson to Call U.S. House Back to Capitol Hill to Pass Emergency Appropriations Funding Following Hurricanes Helene & Milton

WASHINGTON, D.C. — U.S. Representative Abigail Spanberger is urging U.S. House Speaker Mike Johnson to call Members of Congress back to Capitol Hill to pass supplemental appropriations funds to support Virginia’s communities and communities across the Southeastern United State in the wake of Hurricanes Helene and Milton. In a letter to Speaker Johnson, Spanberger and […]



Oct 10, 2024
Good Governance

NEW: Spanberger Ranked #1 Most Collaborative Member of Congress from Virginia, #3 in the Country

An “A” Bridge Grade is Given to Members of Congress Who Exemplify Governing Behaviors that Bridge Our Country Rather than Divide It WOODBRIDGE, Va. — U.S. Representative Abigail Spanberger this week was ranked as the most collaborative Member of Congress from Virginia — and the third most collaborative lawmaker on Capitol Hill. Bridge Grades score […]